No Win No Fee

Free Initial Consultations

The long-awaited final report of Ms Donna Ockenden, Senior Midwife was published earlier this week, on 30 March 2022.  This report follows on from Ms Ockenden’s previous report published in December 2020.


Ms Ockenden was assisted in preparing the report by an independent team of medical professionals in various areas including obstetrics, neonatology, obstetric anaesthesia, physician, cardiology and neurology.


The review forming the basis of the report is the largest ever inquiry in the history of the NHS into a single service.


Whilst Ms Ockenden clearly acknowledges the difficult and much appreciated work carried out by NHS staff throughout the country, which continues in often challenging circumstances, especially considering the Covid pandemic, she has highlighted some truly shocking failures in the quality of care provided and governance at the Trust.


The report also highlights failures from bodies external to the Trust to effectively monitor the care provided by the Trust.




The Independent review was commissioned by the then Secretary for State for Health and Social Care, the Right Honourable Jeremy Hunt MP in 2017.   The review was prompted by the parents of Kate Stanton Davies and Pippa Griffiths whose daughters had died at the midwifery-led units run by The Shrewsbury and Telford Hospital NHS Trust, as a result of the care they received in 2009 and 2016 respectively.


As noted by Ms Ockenden:


“This review owes its origins to Kate Stanton Davies, and her parents Rhiannon Davies and Richard Stanton; and to Pippa Griffiths, and her parents Kayleigh and Colin Griffiths. Kate’s and Pippa’s parents have shown an unrelenting commitment to ensuring their daughters’ short lives make a difference to the safety of maternity care.”


The review was originally concerned with 23 families’ cases, as identified by the parents of Kate Stanton Davies and Pippa Griffiths to Mr Hunt.  The number of cases and the scope of the review increased substantially and Ms Ockenden’s review took evidence from 1,486 families, regarding 1,592 clinical incidents mostly occurring between 2000 and 2019.  Although the earliest incident occurred in 1973 and the latest in 2020.


Report Findings


As noted above, the report found repeated failures in the quality of care and governance over the period considered, together with failures of external bodies to effectively monitor the care provided.


The review found repeated errors in care, which led to injury to either mothers or, their babies.  All aspects of clinical care were considered in maternity services.


The review identified continued failures to follow national clinical guidelines in many areas for example, the monitoring of fetal heart rate, maternal blood pressure, management of gestational diabetes or resuscitation.


The report presents specific incidences including those of Kate Stanton Davies and Pippa Griffiths and the strikingly similar circumstances of prior cases.


There were delays within the Trust to escalate matters to more senior specialists and a failure to work collaboratively across disciplines.  The results of these systemic failures were truly tragic and led to serious medical conditions such as sepsis, hypoxic ischaemic encephalopathy and death.


The report highlighted a fear of midwives to express their concerns to consultants within the Trust, resulting from poor working relationships.  This culture of fear was combined with staffing problems and a lack of training.  These difficulties were played out in front of families, which put additional stress on parents at times when they were at their most vulnerable.


The review detailed repeated circumstances where families were not treated with the sympathy or, compassion they should have expected.  With clinicians unprepared for follow up discussions, not dealing appropriately with complaints, giving inaccurate information and even blaming the parents themselves for the outcomes.


Within the Trust there was an emphasis on promotion of natural birth, with a reluctance to perform caesarean sections.  This directly resulted in babies dying during or, shortly after birth or, alternatively being left with catastrophic, life-long heath conditions.


The review’s consideration of clinical governance processes shows that investigatory processes were not followed to a standard that would have been expected. As noted by Ms Ockenden:


“The reviews were often cursory, not multidisciplinary and did not identify the underlying systemic failings and some significant cases of concern were not investigated at all. In fact, the maternity governance team inappropriately downgraded serious incidents to a local investigation methodology in order to avoid external scrutiny, so that the true scale of serious incidents at the Trust went unknown until this review was undertaken.”


This meant that there were missed opportunities to learn from the incidents occurring within the Trust with continued and repeated serious mistakes and omissions, leading to further avoidable injuries and deaths to Mothers and babies.




The report graded the care provided in four categories as follows:


0, Appropriate, Appropriate care in line with best practice at the time

1, Minor concerns, Care could have been improved, but different management would have made no difference to the outcome

2, Significant concerns, Suboptimal care in which different management might have made a difference to the outcome

3, Major concerns, Suboptimal care in which different management would reasonably be expected to have made a difference to the outcome


The review listed five major incident categories; Maternal death, Stillbirth, Hypoxic Ischaemic Encephalopathy, Neonatal death and Cerebral Palsy/Brain damage.


The review found that for the care provided in categories 2 and 3, and consequently avoidable outcomes, there were Nine maternal deaths, 131 still births, 70 neonatal deaths and 94 cases of brain damage.


Future Developments


The report identified more than 60 specific Local Actions for Learning for Shrewsbury and Telford Hospital NHS covering nine areas and another 15 Immediate and Essential Actions for all maternity services in England.  The aim of these actions is to improve all maternity services in England, including financing a safe and sustainable maternity and neonatal workforce and ensuring appropriate training for all those involved in maternity services.


The report acknowledged the recent announcement of £127 million by NHS England for maternity services but noted that this was significantly short of the £200-£300 million recommended in June 2021 by the Health and Social Care Select Committee.




The individual mistakes identified within the investigation are, sadly, nothing out of the ordinary and are regularly encountered in our work.  What is striking, however, is the shear scale of the problem and the number of families affected, suggesting a significant cultural problem within the trust.


If you have been affected by failings in maternity care, then please feel free to contact us for free and informal initial guidance on the options available to you.

5 Common Birth Injuries


By nature, birth injuries to babies are unexpected and it can be completely devastating for parents and the family. A birth injury is when a baby suffers injury before, during, or after birth. It can be upsetting and you may have feelings of anger and confusion over what has happened.

Some injuries are not foreseeable or may not have been preventable, however, some birth injuries may be due to the substandard level of care provided by medical professionals, such as doctors or midwives. The injury may have been due to an issue that was overlooked during pregnancy or may have been due to a problem that was not correctly treated which may have led to a birth injury.

If your baby had suffered a birth injury and you are concerned about the care that you received during pregnancy or labour, then please get in touch with our birth injury solicitors. Our expert medical negligence solicitors are vastly experienced in helping parents seeking medical compensation as a result of birth injuries.

Many of our cases involve birth injuries as shown below:

Cerebral Palsy

Cerebral Palsy is characterised by a lack of motor skill development, muscle spasms, and weak muscles. In many cases, this condition can be caused by damage to the baby’s brain during birth. There could be various reasons for the damage occurring, such as improper birthing techniques, inadequate monitoring of the mother in labour, and/or inadequate monitoring of foetal distress during labour.

These situations may lead to cerebral palsy and whilst surgery can help the child, it is not a permanent cure. This condition could lead to other health issues, such as hearing and vision impairments, speech difficulties, and learning disabilities. To help manage the symptoms of cerebral palsy, long-term therapy may be needed.


Brachial Plexus

A brachial plexus injury (BPI) occurs when the nerves in the baby’s neck are damaged during delivery. These injuries may involve nerve damages from the upper spins to the neck, shoulder, arm, and hand. The most common type of brachial plexus injury is known as Erb’s Palsy or Erb’s Duchenne palsy, and this usually affects the shoulder and the upper arm.

If a baby has a BPI, then it could result in either a temporary or permanent loss of sensation or movement in the arm. The nerve damage can occur if the nerves are compressed, stretched, or in severe cases, separated from the spinal cord. The more severe cases involving torn or ruptured nerves may fail to heal correctly.


Shoulder Dystocia

Although shoulder dystocia is a rare problem that could occur during the baby’s delivery, it can happen and it approximately affects about 1 in every 150 deliveries. This complication is when the baby’s head is born but one of its shoulders becomes stuck behind the mother’s pubic bone. It’s important to know that this is not a birth injury in its own right, but the risks that are associated with shoulder dystocia are serious. If this complication is not managed and handled correctly, then it could lead to birth injury of the baby.

Doctors and midwives are trained to recognise the signs of shoulder dystocia and will have the right measures to carry out a safe delivery. However, if an inadequate level of care was provided, then there could be serious consequences.


Broken Bones During Delivery

During the delivery stage, babies are at risk of broken or fractured bones due to a variety of reasons. These broken bones or bone fractures can be caused by excessive pulling or twisting of the baby during delivery, the overly forceful use of forceps, or simply due to shoulder dystocia.

Fractures in the shoulder bone are the most common type and babies that have bone diseases are particularly at risk. With ultrasound, certain types of bone disease can be detected but it may not be possible in every case. It’s important to know that some bone fractures are unavoidable as giving birth can be physically demanding on the mother. The natural force of the mother’s contraction may sometimes be enough to cause a fracture; however, this is rare and the baby can make a full recovery with the right care and treatment.


Oxygen Deprivation

Oxygen deprivation could occur during the delivery of the baby which could lead to brain injuries. As a result of these brain injuries, it can cause cerebral palsy or chronic seizures. If the doctor does not properly monitor the baby during birth or after, or the baby remains in the birth canal for too long, then brain injuries may occur.

There are two main types of oxygen deprivation; anoxia and hypoxia. Anoxia is when a baby is completely deprived of oxygen which means that the baby’s brain could sustain an injury. Even just a few minutes without oxygen could have a lifelong impact. Hypoxia is when there is a reduced flow of oxygen to the baby’s brain. The restricted flow of oxygen to the brain could also cause lifelong effects.


Although some birth injuries may not have been preventable, there are babies who should have been born healthy but have been injured due to an inadequate level of care. Parents want to ensure that their baby has a good quality of life and we can help parents through this situation. Our medical negligence solicitors are committed to finding an explanation of what happened and we can help parents to seek a settlement to help alleviate the financial pressures associated with caring for a child who has sustained a birth injury.


Contact BTTJ Medical Negligence for Birth Injury Claims

We understand how upsetting it can be to talk about what has happened and how overwhelming the consequences of clinical negligence are. At BTTJ Medical Negligence, we have a team of legal professionals and medical negligence specialists who are exceptionally experienced at handling these types of cases. All advice and information are treated with total confidentiality, compassion, and care.

If you have suffered from birth injury negligence and you would like to discuss a birth injury claim, then please get in touch with us to see how we can help.

You can call us on 0800 032 2474 or you can send us an email here.